Ok, first up, Kraftwerk’s “Das Model” or “The Model”
She’s a model and she’s looking good
I’d like to take her home that’s understood
She plays hard to get, she smiles from time to time
It only takes a camera to change her mind
She’s going out tonight but drinking just champagne
And she has been checking nearly all the men
She’s playing her game and you can hear them say
She is looking good, for beauty we will pay
She’s posing for consumer products now and then
For every camera she gives the best she can
I saw her on the cover of a magazine
Now she’s a big success, I want to meet her again
And next up, YMO’s “La Femme Chinoise” or “中国女” (Originally, 1978, but this is the live Budokan 1983 version – my personal favorite.)
Compare the riffs in the bass line and the arpeggio, as well as the melody lines and the choice for synthesizer. Lyrics are “Fu Manchu and Suzie-Q, and the girls of the floating world; Junk sails on a yellow sea, while Suzie Wong at Shanghai knows. Suzie can soothe away all your blues; she’s the mistress, the scent of the Orient.”
This is a 1978 version…
What interests me is that they have so many similarities, but the YMO version tends to mystify the feminization of the Orient and the old fantasies that go along with it. They mention “Fu Manchu,” Sax Rohmer’s personification of the “Yellow Peril” and the “Floating World.” What are they saying? Especially in contrast to the Kraftwerk song?
YMO, or “Yellow Magic Orchestra” was an attempt to be tongue-in-cheek about Asian culture and often were cheeky with their ironic anti-stereotype-stereotypes.
Both Kraftwerk and YMO were kind of iconoclastic and anti-establishment with their social commentary, but in totally different ways.
Or, as this website puts it,
“Yellow Magic Orchestra took Kraftwerk’s blueprint for synthesizer driven dance music and exploded it. Where Kraftwerk were rigid and precise, Yellow Magic Orchestra were loose and sloppy. Where Kraftwerk had a seriousness of purpose, Yellow Magic Orchestra were playful and whimsical. Where Kraftwerk had an unwavering thematic unity, Yellow Magic Orchestra were all over the place. Where Kraftwerk sang in German about dancing automatons, Yellow Magic Orchestra sang in English and French about Suzy soothing away all your blues. Where Kraftwerk picked one sound per song and hammered it for eight minutes, Yellow Magic Orchestra took plenty of left turns. Where Kraftwerk were fun in a German, “I’m mocking you and myself on another level that you’ll never understand” kind of way, Yellow Magic Orchestra were fun in an overt, lifting-the-outhouse-up-with-a-crane-while-some-poor-guy is taking a s**t kind of way.”